Private Pay vs. Broker Rides: The Truth About Starting an NEMT Business Most advice about starting a non-emergency medical transportation business skips the part that actually decides whether you survive: where your rides come from and what they pay. In Episode 113 of the NEMT Experts Podcast, Bambi CEO Nirav Chheda sat down with Mackenzie Andrews and Raymond Damitio, the owners of The Doctor Ride in Charlotte, North Carolina, for an un-filtered conversation about that exact question.
Their answer is blunt. They built The Doctor Ride around premium private-pay service and largely steered clear of the broker grind. Here is why, and what they think every new operator should take from it.
The broker model is a trap for a lot of new operators Ray does not mince words about how a big share of the industry actually works.
"Most of this industry is just a cycling circus of NEMT businesses. They start up, they do broker rides, they run out of business, and then a new NEMT business comes up in their place," he said. "The broker model is vicious because they just prey on that."
The math is the problem. Between insurance that rarely runs under a thousand dollars a month per vehicle, rising fuel costs, and broker reimbursement rates that have not kept pace, the spread on a broker ride can be razor thin or negative once you are paying a driver. As Nirav put it, the top line is not the story: "I could give a crap about top line. What's your bottom line?"
That does not make brokers useless. It means new operators should go in with eyes open about what those rides really pay, instead of assuming volume alone will carry the business.
Why The Doctor Ride bet on premium private pay Instead of competing on price for broker volume, Mac and Ray positioned The Doctor Ride as a premium service and charged accordingly. The experience is the product.
"We're showing up at their front door with an umbrella if it's raining, giving them a bottle of water in the car," Mac said. "I treat them like my grandparents."
That standard is not just feel-good. It drives repeat business and reviews, including riders who left for a cheaper provider, had a bad experience, and came back. In a category most people treat as a commodity, service is what stops the comparison shopping.
Put your pricing on the website to pre-qualify riders One of the most practical moves from the episode: The Doctor Ride publishes its pricing right on its site, including a ride-estimate tool. Most operators hide their rates. Mac and Ray do the opposite on purpose.
The logic is that you want people to disqualify themselves before they ever call. If someone balks at the price, they were almost never a few dollars away from booking. They wanted to spend dramatically less. The riders who say yes already understand they are paying for a premium experience, which makes every conversation easier and every ride more profitable.
Google reviews are their number one inbound engine Ask where private-pay riders come from, and the answer is reviews. Riders who research The Doctor Ride see a wall of strong Google reviews and call. That reputation, earned one umbrella-to-the-door ride at a time, has become the top of their funnel and a moat competitors cannot copy overnight.
Collaborate with local competitors instead of hoarding leads Another mindset shift worth stealing: when you cannot cover a ride, hand it to a trusted local operator instead of letting the lead die. As Nirav noted, plenty of successful operators grow precisely because they collaborate. If a rider submits a request and the ride gets fulfilled, by your van or a partner's, that rider comes back to you next time. The relationship is the asset.
The Doctor Ride is also experimenting with a membership for high-frequency riders, like dialysis patients who need transport several times a week, offering a monthly rate that makes regular service more affordable while keeping the schedule full.
Why NEMT holds steady through any economy The throughline is confidence in the category. "It doesn't matter if the economy sucks. They care about their health," the guys said. An aging population is not going to stop needing rides to the doctor, which makes well-run NEMT resilient in a way a lot of small businesses are not.
The takeaway for new operators The Doctor Ride is early, honest about what they are still figuring out, and clear on the strategy: build a brand, deliver a premium experience, publish your pricing, earn reviews, and resist the urge to chase low-paying broker volume just to keep the wheels turning.
Watch the full conversation: NEMT Experts Podcast Episode 113 on YouTube
Keep learning Running NEMT and tired of fighting your software to handle real-world pricing and scheduling? See how Bambi makes it easy .
.png)
Comments
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique. Duis cursus, mi quis viverra ornare, eros dolor interdum nulla, ut commodo diam libero vitae erat. Aenean faucibus nibh et justo cursus id rutrum lorem imperdiet. Nunc ut sem vitae risus tristique posuere.