The NEMT Providers Perspective | Challenges with NEMT Brokers

Non-Emergency Medical Transportation (NEMT) plays a crucial role in ensuring millions of people can access necessary healthcare services. However, the industry faces numerous challenges, particularly when it comes to the relationship between NEMT providers and brokers.

We recently were able to get a group of NEMT providers and brokers together virtually to shed light on the current state of NEMT, highlighting key insights and concerns on the industry.

NEMT Broker Profit Models and the Impact on NEMT Providers

One of the core issues raised revolves around how each NEMT brokers generates revenue. Primarily, brokers earn money through two mechanisms:

1. On-demand payments: Brokers receive payment each time a member uses the NEMT service, along with an administrative fee.
2. Per-month-per-user payments: Insurance companies pay a fixed rate per member, regardless of whether they use the service, plus an admin fee. This model can incentivize brokers to prioritize maximizing the number of covered members rather than ensuring efficient service utilization.

One NEMT owner notes that a significant portion of broker profit often stems from healthcare providers in the broker network who are unaware they have NEMT coverage and never utilize the service. One participant said "I would estimate that about 45% of the people (healthcare facilities) I reached out to did not have any clue that the service was a thing." This disconnect between healthcare facilities and the benefits available to them raises concerns about the effectiveness of the current system.

Challenges for NEMT Providers

NEMT providers working with brokers face several obstacles, including:

• Dependence on Brokers: Providers are reliant on brokers for trip assignments, and negative feedback or blacklisting can lead to a sudden loss of business. One participant noted: "You are beholden to them and the trips that they give you." 
• Outdated Systems and Poor Training: Brokers may not invest in adequate technology or training, leading to miscommunication and missed trips.
• Lack of Support: NEMT providers may feel their concerns are not taken seriously by brokers, even when they experience significant issues impacting their ability to serve members.
• Dispatch Agent Errors: Underpaid and overworked agents may make mistakes that negatively affect providers' operations and income.
• Potential for In-House Competition: Brokers may develop their own NEMT provider services, potentially displacing existing providers in the future. "Most brokers are creating in-house providers in an attempt to replace their contracts." according to one participant. 

Conclusion

NEMT is a vital service, but the current landscape presents significant challenges for providers. Addressing issues such as communication breakdowns, inadequate technology, and power imbalances between NEMT brokers and providers is crucial for ensuring the sustainability and effectiveness of NEMT services.

Furthermore, efforts to improve member awareness and access to NEMT benefits are essential for maximizing the impact of these services and ensuring that individuals can receive the care they need.

‍

‍